I’ve lived in Raleigh and Austin, two capitals in states which might be altering however conservative. And I’ve discovered that sweeping predictions are perilous.

AUSTIN, Texas — A lot about this election yr has been weird and unprecedented, however one factor remained the identical: I spent hours crushing the goals of family and friends from across the nation by telling them that, no, red-hot Texas wouldn’t go blue.

I shouted right into a gale power wind of hypothesis from pundits in and out of doors the state, powered by hopeful polls and statements like these: “Texas is aggressive this yr, and it’s rather more aggressive than we’ve seen for 20 years.” (James Henson, director of the Texas Politics Venture on the College of Texas at Austin). “Turnout is totally unprecedented, and also you higher wager that the oldsters who’re turning out will not be turning out to maintain the established order.” (Harris County Decide Lina Hidalgo). “Hell sure.” (Texas Democratic Get together Government Director Manny Garcia, requested whether or not this was the yr Texas would go blue.)

Associates in New York, the place I grew up, have been stunned after I instructed them {that a} state they regard as redeemable if solely of us right here will see issues their method … simply don’t. At the least not but.

Texas is altering however nonetheless conservative

It gave me no pleasure to be proper. President Donald Trump handily received the state’s 38 electoral votes. Texans returned Republican John Cornyn to the U.S. Senate. 

The refrain of hopeful voices predicting that Democrats would choose up anyplace from 9 seats within the state Home, which they wanted to take the bulk, to an outlandish 16 seats, was snuffed out. When legislators return to Austin in January, Republicans will maintain 83 seats and Democrats 67, the identical partisan break up as two years in the past. Democrats gained one seat within the state Senate, however Republicans nonetheless maintain an 18-13 majority. All statewide places of work are nonetheless held by Republicans.

I moved to Austin from Washington, D.C., in 2002 after touring the nation masking George W. Bush’s 2000 marketing campaign after which masking him on the White Home. Earlier than that, I reported in North Carolina, the place I lived in Raleigh and lined the statehouse, and I’ve watched from afar as Republican dominance has change into entrenched there. It was no shock that my former dwelling additionally went for Trump, its swing state standing swinging to the Republicans in 5 out of the previous six presidential elections. 

My expertise residing in two capitals in states which might be altering however nonetheless basically conservative has taught me that sweeping predictions are perilous. Change could be coming to Texas, however it’s going to arrive step-by-step, one ahead, one again, a actuality the hyperbole obscured. The Trump indicators only a one-hour drive in any course from the liberal capital of Austin — together with Johnson Metropolis, the childhood dwelling of Democratic titan Lyndon B. Johnson — have been a reminder for anyone who wanted one.

Longtime Democratic stalwarts perceive this actuality. My neighbor, a 70-something lifelong Democrat who served because the elected Travis County tax assessor-collector, by no means stops sending fundraiser invitations for Democratic candidates up and down the poll. A well-qualified and extremely revered district court docket choose ran for chief justice of the Texas Supreme Court docket this cycle. The uphill, dropping battle was a step within the march towards the sometime of getting only one Democrat on the state’s highest court docket.

Nothing to lose: I am from Texas and here is my recommendation for Democrats: Go for it.

There are causes to be hopeful, nevertheless it’s essential to research them with out seizing on hope over expertise. For every step ahead, there’s a step again:

►Trump’s margin of victory — 52.1% to 46.5% — shrank from 2016, when he beat Hillary Clinton by 9 factors. That stated, the softened assist on the high of the poll didn’t translate to nice features for down-ballot Democrats.

Democrats held on to Hispanic and Latino voters in South Texas and the Rio Grande Valley alongside the Texas-Mexico border. That stated, the margin was lower than half of Clinton’s in 2016 (my husband, a Texas native and longtime politics reporter, groused that the fixed texts asking for cash ought to have been parlayed into on-the-ground, if socially distanced, campaigning on this essential area for Democrats). 

Trump and GOP dominate rural Texas

►Joe Biden received the state’s 4 main metropolitan areas — Bexar, Dallas, Harris and Travis counties — and picked up the final Republican city stronghold, Tarrant County. He additionally received the suburban counties of Hays and Williamson, outdoors of Austin. The final Democrat to hold any of those three counties was Johnson, in 1964. That stated, these victories didn’t overtake Trump’s overwhelming dominance in rural Texas.

►The state’s inhabitants is continuous to shift from rural to extra city and suburban. However whether or not this shift is transferring quick sufficient to repay for the subsequent Democratic presidential candidate stays an open query.

Actual working class voted Biden: Republicans as a multicultural working class celebration? That is Trump-level delusional pondering.

Voter turnout was dramatic, nevertheless it didn’t translate to huge wins for Democrats. Smarting from 2018, when Democrats took 12 seats within the Texas Home and two seats within the Texas Senate and virtually misplaced Sen. Ted Cruz’s seat, Republicans got here roaring again.

►Gov. Greg Abbott’s determination to lengthen early voting in all probability benefited Democrats. On the similar time, the abolition of the one-punch straight ticket voting doubtless labored to the benefit of some Republican legislative candidates, encouraging voters who have been cautious of Trump to reject him however say sure to them.

I’ve come to like Texas, and I’m rooting for it to change into a extra equitable place. I wish to cease grinding my enamel over the woefully underfunded public faculties and having the very best share of residents with out medical health insurance. Will that day be nearer 4 years from now when my cellphone begins buzzing with questions on a Democratic presidential candidate successful the day?

Possibly, however I’m not betting the farm on it.

Jena Heath is an affiliate dean on the Faculty of Arts & Humanities at St. Edward’s College, an affiliate professor of Journalism and Digital Media and coordinator of the Journalism and Digital Media program.​​​​ Beforehand, she was reporter who lined cops, courts, native and state authorities, and the 2000 Bush marketing campaign and White Home. Observe her on Twitter: @JenaHeath2


Present Thumbnails

Present Captions

Learn or Share this story: https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/voices/2020/11/30/trump-republicans-dominate-rural-texas-hope-for-democrats-column/6457039002/